Monday, February 20, 2012

Response to Classmate Jenna Harvie's "Oddity- Family Licks," Week 5

First of all, extremely odd on your family's part, but definitely relate-able for most families. Second, I think you should expand upon this essay since "there's no place too inappropriate." Even though you provide some intimate moments when this greeting has occurred, I want to know the most inappropriate place this has happened to you or even someone you know. How old were you, and how did you react? Did you remain calm and collected or did you vacate the premises immediately? Has anyone besides yourself performed this greeting on your boyfriend? If so, what happened? Reflect a little here. Third, your "instructions" on how to perform the greeting are laid out with clarity with a reportage tone but with specific language choices to intrigue the reader to continue and imagine the greeting taking place. Lastly, I like the imagery you apply to the different experiences of licking your family members. You don't linger on the adjectives, but provide enough details to balance out the essay, keeping it clean and interesting with a sense of reality. You chose distinct physical feelings, smells, tastes that most people know or have experienced which allows your story to be relate-able to those with similar “traditions” and to those who know how a stubbed toe on concrete feels. 

No comments:

Post a Comment